Essay on entrapment
Publié le 10/06/2025
Extrait du document
«
Comparative essay
Lara, Lilia, Mohi, Manon
I - Entrapment in society
Topic sentence: In order to explore the theme of entrapment, Lynn Nottage and the women poets,
through structure and symbolism, represent and illustrate women gender norms but also question
their role in women entrapment.
A.
Form/ structure : First of all, In intimate apparel, Nottage explores the theme of entrapment
through the use of structure and stagecraft.
Indeed, she uses detailed descriptions of the
setting, particularly the decor, to emphasize the limitations and confined nature of Esther's
world.
For example, the detailed description of Esther's room in Act 1, Scene 1, underscores
the mundane and restricted life she leads.
The limitations of her physical space mirror the
limitations placed on her by society and her circumstances serving as a visual representation
of the entrapment within prescribed gender roles and societal norms.
Moreover, the strategic
use of silence between characters, particularly evident in interactions between Esther and Mr.
Marks like in Act 2, Scene 4, as they navigate the complexities of their relationship, which
adds a layer of tension to the narrative.Unspoken feelings and unexpressed desires linger in
the silence, symbolizing the constraints imposed by societal expectations.
The palpable
tension becomes a reflection of the characters' entrapment within their social roles.
Besides,
the recurring use of Ragtime as in the beginning of the play :”A clumsy ragtime melody bleeds
in from the parlour”, serves as a symbolic representation of the era and also mirrors the
emotional ups and downs of the characters.The characters are entrapped in a cultural and
emotional cadence that dictates their lives, limiting their freedom of expression.
Furthermore,
lighting choices, such as dimmed lights during intense moments, accentuate the characters'
emotional states, reinforcing the characters' entrapment within the societal norms that govern
their relationships.
Finally, the concept of photographs at the end of each act, even if not
physically present in the book, symbolizes the characters' entrapment within the past.
Each
photograph captures a frozen moment in time, reflecting the historical and personal contexts
that shape the characters' present circumstances.
Similarly, Emily Dickinson also uses the structure of her poem “I’m “wife” — I’ve finished
that—“ in order to convey a feeling of entrapment.
Indeed the author structures her poem with
excessive dashes, twelve to be precise.
This use of dashes breaks the fluidity of the poem.
It
seems as if the parts of the verses were trapped between the dashes.
Added to this the poem
is cut into three stanzas.
Furthermore her work showcases a woman torn between two states
: womanhood and being a wife.
She describes how hard it is to detach herself from the
burden of being the wife of someone.
Unfortunately, at the end she finds herself trapped
inside the same state.
The exclamation point
in the last verse of the poem shows that the narrator can’t escape from wifehood and
therefore from the societal entrapment she is living in because of her gender.
Thus, the
structure of the poem reinforces this feeling of entrapment specially present in marriage by
breaking the speech of the protagonist with dashes and through the division of the poem into
three stanzas, preventing her from emancipating from the social expectations.
B.
Symbolism and Imagery : Moreover, Lynn Nottage, with the stagecraft of the corset tries
to raise awareness about the powerful way this symbol illustrates and allows her to criticize
women's pressure imposed by society.
Indeed, the symbol of the corset is representing the
garment, a physical mark of imprisonment used to show the imprisonment of women to the
spectator.
Yet Lynn Nottage also criticizes the fact that this imposed cage is seen and pushed
by society as a norm and fashion accessory.
For instance, with the “Wedding Corset: White
Satin with pink roses” destined for Corina Mae, allows Lynn Nottage to introduce the pressure
women of the time, embodied by Esther, felt to marry.
Furthermore, the “Gardenia Ball corset:
Pink silk and crepe de chine'' designed for Ms.
Van Buren that “hardly seems decent''
denounces the paradoxical moral pressure put on women to dress decently while fulfilling
their role of wife, which meant to stay desirable for their husband.
This quote “hardly seems
decent” from Mrs Van Buren in her boudoir with Esther, highlights how the intimacy of the
undergarment affected women in their relationships during the 20th century.
The settings
serve to explore the imposition of this garment as physical and symbolic entrapment for
women.
To sum up, Lynn Nottage demonstrates that women are trapped in the private sphere
where they have to fulfill the role society assigned them and hence through the symbol of
corsets, she represents the society’s mindset concerning women’s place.
Likewise, Elizabeth Bishop uses symbols in “One Art”.
The gradation of the elements the poet
loses are allegories for the grief she is going through.
From materialistic objects without any
value to emotional valued things, Bishop states everything she loves (“loved houses”, “lovely
[cities]”, “ a gesture [she] love[s]”, especially “[her] mother’s watch” and “losing faster, losing
farther” that sound like losing her father) as a metaphor for grief, only to share her personal
experience of losing it all.
Characteristic of the confessional poetry, Bishop testifies of her life
to raise awareness of her audience.
With the gradation of symbolic elements, Elizabeth
Bishop reminds the readers they are trapped in the unavoidable pain of loss and grief they
have to face to “master”.
Author’s purpose: By representing the entrapment of numerous female characters for Lynn Nottage
and of the speaker for the women poets, gender norms are explored and denounced as element
favorating female immobility, suggesting the intersectionality between all the texts.
II 1-A
In order to break entrapment, Lynn Nottage creates characters that defy and exude the
confinement of entrapment through the use of contrast and foil characters.
As a matter of fact, Lynn
Nottage stages two opposite characters in Intimate Apparel: Mrs Van Buren and Mayme.
The first one
is an educated white woman free to live a more luxurious lifestyle because she goes to the opera, to
the “the annual Gardenia Ball, quite the event of the season” in act I sc 2.
Yet, this illusion of choice
and freedom she gives hides the reality: she’s controlled by society’s norms (“one of those things
required of [her]”, like her life is commanded by someone) and she’s completely dependent on her
husband due to social expectations (“he spat at [her]” Lynn Nottage gives him an abusive
characterization to illustrate the patriarchal society”).
Thus to break this situation of entrapment, Lynn
Nottage invents her foil character: Maymee, a black prostitute.
By definition, they are complete
opposites, Mayme’s characterization is thought to reverse the situation of entrapment created....
»
↓↓↓ APERÇU DU DOCUMENT ↓↓↓